Politics & Government

POLL: Should Breastfeeding Moms be Exempt from Serving on Juries?

If legislators latch onto a bill circulating in Lansing, nursing moms will get an automatic exception.

Breastfeeding mothers may soon claim exemption from jury service if a house bill referred to the state senate Judiciary Committee makes it’s way into Michigan law in 2012.

HB 4691 makes an exception for a breastfeeding mother who provides a letter from a physician, lactation consultant or certified midwife verifying she is nursing.

Evelyn Moses, 39, was a nursing mother in 2009 when she got a jury summons from the in Royal Oak.

Find out what's happening in Royal Oakwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Moses told the Detroit Free Press that when she called the courthouse, a clerk told her that breastfeeding wasn't reason enough to be exempt. Only after appearing in person with a doctor's note did she get to postpone her service until her baby was weaned.

Royal Oak attorney Mike Steinberg doesn't care for the proposed legislation, even if it is well-intentioned.

Find out what's happening in Royal Oakwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

“If we start watering down who can serve, there will be a clamor from others who will want exceptions,” Steinberg said. “The next thing you know it will be people who wear red dresses. It’s a step toward diluting the jury pool.”

Steinberg says the constitution envisioned a true cross-section of society serving on juries.

“If a woman is capable of pumping, she’s capable of serving on a jury,” he said.

What do you think?

Are you inclined to agree that such a law would lead to other groups asking for exemptions?

Do you believe allowing an automatic nursing exemption denies a defendant a true cross-section of his or her peers on the jury that determines a verdict?

Or is this just a common-sense thing: Nursing mothers shouldn’t have to be away from their babies, and shouldn't be forced to pump?


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here